Recent Comments

Help us pick our April fishing cover


We can’t decide which cover to use for April’s special fishing issue, so we need your opinion. Which cover do you like best?

Vote for your favorite in the poll below, and tell us why in the comments.

26 Comments on Help us pick our April fishing cover

  1. BoyslifeLuver14 // September 27, 2014 at 7:43 am // Reply

    I Love The One On The Left because it shows What fun it is to fish

  2. I like the 1st one best

  3. I would have to go with the one on the left because it actually has a fish in it

  4. I think 2 is better because the other one is just here is a fish. The 2nd cover makes you interested because the scout is interested in his task.

  5. Legolover2000 // December 1, 2013 at 12:57 pm // Reply

    The second pic 4 the covr
    because it expresses a boys intrest 🙂

  6. The picture on Cover 2 is more pleasing to look at, for me.

  7. cover 2 is more interesting.

  8. I like cover A it symbolizes success

  9. Do_I_Really_Need_A_Nickname? // November 29, 2013 at 6:09 pm // Reply

    1 because some people may not know what #2 is. Also, cover 1 shows that hard work and practice pays off in that boy’s huge fish!

  10. Pick the first one! You can’t even tell what the kid in the second one is doing…

  11. Pee-Wee Harris // November 28, 2013 at 8:39 am // Reply

    There is a large blurry lump in the foreground of cover 2. Other than that, both of them are fine. However, the second one has knot tying in it, which relates more specifically to Boy Scouts, so I would have chosen that one instead if not for the lump in the foreground.

  12. vote #1 so you can be boss like me

  13. i like cover one

  14. it looks better

  15. Why not use both covers, April Cover Fly Tying and May the catch

  16. Cover one is better

  17. Cover two would be better if it didn’t have the big blurry hand at the bottom.

  18. Cover 1 is over used as a cover for fishing. Cover 2 is very well composed and a bit different.

  19. Love both but really wanted to showcase the youth with his hobby as the highlight that he enjoys.

  20. Many people have caught a fish, but few have tied a fly. Also, the tying pic looks like the boy is working with something that is sparking–suggestive of sparking an idea or electricity. I think it tells more of a story. It role models how boys can aspire to create and learn.

  21. I belıeve ti ıs more eye catching and soothıng to the concept of fıshıng.🐠🐟

  22. I believe that the cover should depict the Scout holding the fish. The photograph of the Scout tying the fly may not be immediately noticeable as that to others, especially with the focus of the subject in front of the Scout’s face and the out-of-focus object in the foreground of the photograph.

  23. Use the photo with the fish to generate interest! Most scouts are interested in fishing while many do not know about fly tying!

  24. Love that fish!

  25. Cover 2 shows the skills being learned not just the end result.

  26. I like to see the boys learning a new skill. I know they all like to fish and the fish is neat, but the new skill is key. However, if you look at it from a marketing point of view, I think the boys will like the fish cover better. But from a leader’s point of view, I like the lure better.

Leave a Reply

Please do not use your real name.